I’ve ordered a LOT of proofgrade basswood plywood over the past few months and it’s all been fantastic…until recently a few of the pieces look VERY glossy. As if they’ve got some sort of clear coat on them or something.
We are continually making adjustments and improvements to our Proofgrade, so finish and other minor details may vary, and it looks like that’s what happened here.
But the difference here is like buying a can of paint that says “matte” on it, but then turns out it’s actually “glossy”.
I’ve now got 15 sheets of this “glossy” stuff that doesn’t match any of the other basswood I have.
You could buy some matte spray finish and make them matte
Joking aside, I get complete color differences in my walnut wood orders. I have some that are a deep brown, and others that look like a burnt cherry color. I don’t order much basswood, but mine is somewhere between the two that you have.