Acrylic and MDF Siren Whistle

instructables
acrylic
whistle
siren
mdf

#1

Not sure what they are going to do the maple skinned MDF. The beta Proofgrade I got had a slight warp, but it worked out just fine. I was browsing @m_raynsford’s excellent blog for inspiration and I came across his siren whistle build of an Instructable he’d found.

In chasing down the Instructable, I had a few ideas as to how it would work best with the Glowforge, Proofgrade materials, and the other aspects of the design. I learned a few things in the process and best of all didn’t have to get any CA glue out and all over my fingers.

That design was in turn based on another design out of acrylic, the turbine whistle that looked pretty cool and was a a little bigger, but was glued together. I knew I wanted to avoid sanding. Although both the acrylic and maple MDF are nominal 1/8", in fact that acrylic is slightly thinner and thus would make a perfect turbine to go into the siren without having to sand it thinner to allow for spinning.

With the turbine figured out, then I looked to the fasteners. Bamboo skewers and MIG welding wire were in the bill of materials. Hmmm, I had the skewers but no wire. I did have instead some brass coated brad nails that I picked up for the leather projects. They are 1/2" long and would work well just cutting off the tip with a side cutter.

Then I took a look at the design. This instructable provided only a DXF. There was a brief delay in the process while I figured out what the heck to do with that in Inkscape. The file opened up perfectly but just sat there in the workspace and I could not edit anything. Did a little digging and just couldn’t figure out why they weren’t editable, either as opened or as imported. Something to track down. Update: turns out it is a linked clone that had to be unlinked. (Shift+Alt+D). I had thought that Inkscape managed them fine. In any case there were some online converters I used used on of them to give me some lines to tweak. The paths were not joined and that made some interesting cutting patterns. I had to combine all the single paths that made up the turbine, join them and color them distinct from the rest.

Another issue was how to resize the holes that were for skewers and wires. After selecting all the larger holes for the skewer pins, I scaled them down in place, proportionally applied to each object separately. The transform dialogue box really is your friend. Of course with a parametric program, this would be lots easier.

I scaled the center axle hole up slightly to fit the brads and allow the turbine to spin.

The bamboo skewers we a bit thick for the holes for the first iteration so I whittled down some wooden match sticks. Got lots of those.

The first print worked out ok after assembly and then I did the work to resize for the brass coated brads.

Close your eyes: it ain’t pretty.

Finally the file: I am looking forward to the Glowforge design catalog going live. It is rare that I come across a design that I don’t have to tweak and modify. This particular design presented many little issues that needed attention. Nothing major and nothing that took a lot of time, but something like this should just load and print.

So I cleaned up the design. First I joined all the many path segments that made up the file. Just about every straight and curve section was its own path. The file was just all one color, so I then made the two colors to indicate the two operations needed, one for plywood and the other for acrylic. I also separated the elements into layers. Not strictly necessary, but it is helpful in checking out a design to turn layers on and off to see or isolate things to apply one operation too.

Most important is being able to easily resize the holes to fit whatever material you choose for fasteners and for the axle. Just shift click on the fastener holes and apply the scale transform to size the holes whatever dimension you need them:

Thick, round toothpicks actually would be the easiest option. You could size the holes just enough to be able to friction fit the toothpicks in and easily trim off the ends flush. Just remember to make the axle hole slightly larger than the axle to allow the turbine to spin freely.


Weekly Highlights for the Week Ending January 28th, 2017
#2

Really neat project sir. Can’t wait to hear it.


#3

Let’s get annoying!! :stuck_out_tongue_closed_eyes:


#4

Well, is it annoying? (Great project!) :grinning:


#5

DXFs sometimes have these “grouped” objects that have caused me problems on occasion as well. I forget what they’re called… “instances”, “clusters”, “stickums”… something along those lines. Maybe even simply “objects”.

Anyway, if it’s the same issue as the one linked below, the solution might be to use a tool that’s apparently called “unlink clone” (Shift + Alt + D). (command name and shortcut lifted from the link below, I haven’t actually tried it myself). That thread calls the objects “symbols”.

http://www.inkscapeforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=30497


#6

I think that would be a great project for my wife to use with her first grade class! Near the end of the day of course :wink:

Thanks for sharing!


#7

Nice find/design! Thanks for sharing!


#8

I’m sure the parents would be SO grateful. :scream:


#9

Another great project. Thanks again for documenting all of these.

You’ve inspired me! Now I am thinking about making a big one to bring to my son’s soccer games:


#10

For nearly every niece and nephew around their 2nd or 3rd birthday my mother goes to Goodwill for some pots and pans and then buys some wooden spoons. A colorful paint job later: instant drum set. After a lull there is a new generation of kiddies at the family gatherings. This is going to be so awesome!


#11

Seems like a lot of work for a little annoying thing…although I’ve had my train whistle for years…I bet it came together fast on the GF. Thanks for all the pictures and video and taking us on this little journey with you. - Rich


#12

Boom! Headshot!:+1: That worked. Thanks so much for tracking that down. Unlinking the clone was the key.

And @tim’s Mathias Wandel reference is a classic. He has inspired me in many ways.


#13

I’ve made train whistles for each of my niece and nephews. It takes maybe an hour total labor time to make it. It takes longer to wait for the glue to dry than to make the whole thing.


#14

I might need one to annoy my son to get back to school work… #evilmom :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye::smiling_imp:


#15

I think this will be a fun little project that will use my scraps . Can’t wait for my Glowforge. :grinning:


#16

The video did not play for me. I had to download it to my desktop to see and hear it.


#17

It is always a challenge to do get this right re videos. I ran it through a transform to get it small enough to do an upload. It worked on Chrome on Ubuntu last night but Chrome On Windows10 or safari on iPad. I do know that Discourse makes an intentional effort to not be a video hosting service so there are limitations.


#18

I think it might have been Discourse acting up again. I came back to the post and it loaded fine. I saw Brandon’s remark and thought maybe he was having the same issue as me.