Any ideas on why my engravings seem so shallow / are suddenly not as deep?

[evansd2]

Ah, here we go:

Engrave settings to match Scoring

Suggest you learn a little about how the settings work. Fortunately, they provide some great documentation:

Anyway yes I’d start by working out what settings do what you want and then use a custom setting so you don’t get things changed on you by GF or by virtue of changing the material.