Your results are great! Some really awesome help from @rvogt and @evansd2 !!
These turned out beautifully. I’m sure your daughter will treasure them.
I’m glad I saw this about the curve. I always knew to adjust it and what I needed the photo to look like, but it was always trial and error since I totally didn’t understand what the tonal curve meant at all until I just read your post. Now I know what my histogram needs to look like. Thanks for sharing this information!
well… that’s dependent on the photo. In the case of a relatively balanced black and white picture like this with lights and darks and midtones, yeah a relatively flat curve is what you’re shooting for. but if your image originally has lots of dark shadows and then some midtones, then yeah you will still have a pretty shadow-heavy histogram. It’s more an art than a science as far as I see it, a balance of what you are going for and understanding what your image inherently needs. But I’m glad you found it useful!
Another way to deal with areas like this is the dodge/burn tool in Photoshop. Does Gimp have this? It’s a fairly standard photographic concept from the before-digital days.
Yeah and you can lasso select and alter the curve for this part only too, getting it to match the rest a bit better would be pretty simple. Lots of ways to approach it.