Pencil erasers have grit added to them. I’m not sure what is in the grit, let’s see what google says. I suspect fine mineral grit. BRB.
Generally, erasers that contain silica grit and rubber
So essentially it’s rubber with sand/glass in it. Sand doesn’t laser cleanly, and some erasers are strange polymers with unknown additives. While engraving a pink pencil eraser might work, I’m with @dklgood and would stick with laserable stamp rubber – not worth the risk to find out there’s something harmful added to the eraser.
In case you haven’t seen this, check out #4. It’s some general guidance on materials that can be dangerous to laser: