Settings are going to vary between materials, even if both materials are paper. The best you can really hope for from someone else’s settings is a starting point for your own testing.
I’m confused by your top photo because I can’t really figure out what it’s showing. But what I would do, were I you, is create a small filled shape, make duplicates of it, then on each one change the settings just slightly. Maybe for the first run, keep them all at a power of 8 and decrease the speed by 50 on each one, and see what happens. Or keep the speed the same and bump up the power by 2 points on each one. That’s how you dial in settings. Nobody else can do it for you, if you want to use non-PG materials.